FORTUNE -- Last week's disclosure the Securities and Exchange Commission is conducting an investigation into how IBM reports their cloud computing revenue poses additional queries than answers. The New York-based tech large admitted it is cooperating with all the SEC considering the fact that last May however mentioned very little else in regards to the particulars on the case. One issue is very obvious : It's possible this won't be the very last probe directly into usually inconsistent ways applied to account for software-as-a-service products.
The cloud itself is not the challenge -- it is the approach it is packaged and offered. Unlike ancient, on-premise computer application, cloud-based resources are typically acquired by means of multi-year contracts. Customers are charged a monthly subscription fee, which implies a recurring revenue stream which might be difficult to account for since it spans typically the training program of many several yrs (also because, typically, buyers back again out of every contracts). This gets particularly sophisticated in giant corporations in which lump cloud-computing gross sales in along with non-cloud products.
" Accounting principles were created once we were all trading goods along with one another, " states Tien Tzuo, CEO of Zuora, a billing platform used by almost cloud computing corporations. " As we shift away a manufacturing economy to the service economy it gets fairly advanced. "
MORE : Can social media fix typically the Washington Post?
IBM (IBM) could be a powerful illustration with this phenomenon. Over yesteryear few several yrs, the corporate has actually been shifting from their roots as being a hardware and on-premise computer application vendor, towards a long term as being a cloud and companies purveyor. To in which finish, it is created many acquisitions, as well as a recent $2 billion bid to obtain SoftLayer Technologies, that rents out computing energy to buyers.
" Any time you set 2 corporations along, it is fair to expect they can have marginally totally different accounting practices, " states Cowen & Co. analyst Peter Goldmacher. " These are various companies along with totally different policies and totally different revenue designs. You've received an concerned condition created sophisticated by having totally different delivery designs and accounting practices and putting these people along. "
That's not the ultimate challenge for corporations such as IBM -- and Oracle (ORCL) and SAP (SAP) -- which have created acquisitions within the cloud computing area. This clash of cultures additionally complicates commissions, as a result of salespeople applied to selling ancient computer application are applied to collecting a hefty, one-time look at for each offer they shut. And whilst embracing these new, high-growth technologies are a necessary evolution for so-called legacy corporations, it is not very obvious only how a lot cash they are really creating coming from the cloud as a result of these fledgling businesses in many cases are bundled to, non-cloud products. IBM, for instance, has mentioned their cloud computing business was up 70% throughout the initial half with this year. But it hasn't given any body of reference since it does not really break out what people revenues applied to be or are nowadays.
MORE : What's happening along with Apple as well as the ITC?
It can possible become a whilst prior to investors can convey to precisely what these giant tech corporations are creating from these new businesses and exactly how nicely they are folding inside their cloud-based acquisitions. Even cloud heavyweight Amazon. com (AMZN) is not yet needed to break out revenue from their growing cloud computing products, Amazon Web Services. According to Cowen & Co. 's Goldmacher, investors ought to pause prior to changing into way far much too enamored along with subscription-based revenue, but engaging a recurring revenue stream could seem : "... we're involved in which investors are taking wrong comfort in these designs because of the income statement and balance sheet might be lagging indicators upon the actual trajectory on the business, " he wrote in the recent report. But Goldmacher is additionally quick to note that it can be unlikely something nefarious is being conducted, no matter if typically the SEC has motive to introduction an investigation. " My perception is the fact this is simply very sophisticated, " states Goldmacher. " The additional sophisticated an enterprise typically the more inclined you're to take a mistake. "
In some other words, till these new cloud-computing businesses obtain giant enough to simply need additional transparency -- and till accounting practices for subscription-based products turn out to be additional standardized in any respect tech corporations, giant and small- -- it is possible there will be masses additional mistakes (and SEC investigations) ahead.
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar